COM4234 Advanced Project
A major focus of the Advanced Project is the design and implementation of a research project, the topic of which will be discussed with and approved of by the instructor. Students will undertake advanced reading and will refine their critical analysis skills.
The final report will be graded as follows:
Project: The Ridges
Comments
Every couple of years I receive a proposal for a research project on The Ridges, and I'm always hesitant to approve it. Your proposal was no different in that regard. While I always approve The Ridges proposals in the end, I've never regretted doing so until now.
What you've presented hardly passes as an in-depth study of The Ridges' folklore and history--it barely registers as a vlog about a haunted building. Instead of the critical investigation you promised, you slapped together a video that showcases your friend's alarmingly rapid descent into madness after spending a few hours inside The Ridges.
Your thesis "The Ridges is not haunted" is abandoned in favour of documenting the goings-on in your living room. I can understand, perhaps even forgive you for the change of subject matter, given what happens to your friend, but I cannot understand why you don't seek medical attention for her condition. Your shocking lack of concern for Robbie's well being is unforgivable and you ought to be ashamed of yourself.
Moreover, if she is, in fact, haunted or possessed by the spirit of her great-aunt, then you've disproved your thesis. Meaning, The Ridges is haunted and you have proof of that. What are the spiritual, religious, and intellectual implications of this finding? Truly a missed opportunity there.
Still more puzzling is your choice to include your methodology, such as it is. I know I asked students to outline their research design, but you must know that your approach is damaging to your final grade. The only benefit in including your perfunctory research into The Ridges History and your eleventh-hour attempts to secure access to The Ridges is that I know have an example I can show to future students of how not to approach their advanced research project.
Finally, I must address the nature of your investigation as it appears in the video. Simply having a friend film you as you explore the building is not enough (also, the camera should proceed you). A lack of understanding of, or appreciation for, The Ridges' history clearly shows in the first half of the video. Not once do you provide any context for what's shown on screen, nor do you address past accounts of paranormal or supernatural activity that have taken place. No real research is presented to the viewer, nor do you demonstrate any real awareness of your subject matter. Your video is ninety minutes of you arguing with your friends.
To sum up, your research project, which was to disprove the existence of ghosts with specific attention being paid to The Ridges, fails to demonstrate any of the advanced skills this course was designed to help develop in upper-year students. You show no ability to think critically or independently, nor do you seem capable of conducting independent research.
Grade
F-
Showing posts with label awfulness. Show all posts
Showing posts with label awfulness. Show all posts
Friday, 31 July 2015
Thursday, 23 April 2015
Tin Can Man
"I need a palate cleanser," I said.
"Me too."
Tin Can Man played a whole bunch of festivals, so I thought it had to have some merit. But no. No merit. Unless you consider David Lynch fanfic meritorious. Tin Can Man looks and feels like a student film made by a guy who really likes experimental film, horror movies, and David Lynch. That's me being complimentary.
Me being less charitable reads like this: Tin Can Man is a confused art project made by a guy who hates his audience, the film medium, and quite possibly himself, to boot.
Here's what happens in the movie:
-Pete gets dumped by his girlfriend and is reamed out at work
-A guy claiming to be his neighbour asks to borrow his phone because he had an "accident" and can't use his own phone to make a call
-The neighbour reveals he's not really Pete's neighbour, and that he killed the real neighbour
-Pete and the fake neighbour visit Pete's dad where the fake neighbour introduces himself as Dave
-Dave tells Pete to kill his dad, and Pete refuses
-Dave takes Pete to meet the Tin Can Man, whom Dave kills after forcing him to dance around
-Dave takes Pete to meet his family where they force feed him cake
-Dave turns Pete into the new Tin Can Man
-Pete tries to escape and stops a motorist, who promptly returns him to Dave
-Pete "performs" as the Tin Can Man, which I think is some kind of fever dream but I can't be sure because nothing in this this movie makes any sense so it could be that Pete really is introduced by a clown to an audience of people from his life, and that he really does take the stage and bow to great applause
Now would be the part of the review where I explain what all this means, but I'm not going to do that because I don't know what it means. Moreover, I truly believe the whole thing is completely meaningless. There's no story here, no logic or thought process. There's just Pete who completely fails to learn or grow, and Dave who just talks a lot of nonsense and yells.
Also the whole thing is lit by flashlight. Which really has nothing to do with story, but goes some way in validating the whole "experimental" angle I'm pushing. And experimental film, in my experience, has little interest in storytelling.
I can't fully explain why I disliked Tin Can Man so much, why it made such terrible impression, and left me feeling icky. I have very little time or patience for experimental film, and although I, too, was once a pretentious film student, I got over it. So that likely has something to do with it--why I roll my eyes and make exasperated noises at the mere mention of Tin Can Man. Whatever writer-director Ivan Kavanagh's problem is, he needs to get over it, too.
The poster claims the movie is "truly terrifying" and a "masterpiece." It's not scary, nor does it showcase any sort of mastery of the cinematic medium. Difficult to watch and impossible to appreciate, Tin Can Man is bad art masquerading as genre film.
Labels:
awfulness,
bad writing,
experiment
Friday, 16 March 2012
Alien vs Hunter
I've seen a lot of bad movies, but Alien vs Hunter isn't so much bad as it is irritating to watch. Also, it's really bad. With a blatant disregard for continuity, the film tries to tell the story of a small group of hapless folk who get caught between a giant alien spider and the gun-toting tin man who's hunting it. It succeeds for the most part, but the film so poorly made, it's hard to see the bigger picture.
"Well, it's made by The Asylum," you would say. "What did you expect?"
"Not much," I'd admit. "But I would, at the very least, expect the DOP to be able to frame a shot."
I'm not talking incompetency, like what I experienced watching Playback. I mean the people who made AVH are incapable of filming and editing a movie.
"Uh, didn't you just watch a movie? A movie they made?" you would ask.
"No, what I watched had the shape and form of a movie, but had the look and feel of a failed experiment."
Leaving aside the fact that all The Asylum movies suffer from bad pacing and worse timing, AVH is so badly written as to make you wonder how the script was greenlit. Take for instance the sequence in which Lee and friends go to Valentine's place. Valentine has powerful communications equipment and it's Lee's hope they can use it to contact the military. When they get there, no one makes mention of any satellites or radio transmitters. Rather, Val breaks out his telegraph to contact his...militia buddies? Or there's the scene in which everyone leaves the house--unarmed--to watch the aliens skulk around the front yard. Exactly nothing happens for a couple of minutes and then they all go back inside. And let's not forget the time when Valentine decides he'd rather hunt the aliens than protect his daughter. We're supposed to believe he's being noble but it's just another inexplicable turn in a long series of incomprehensible events.
I understand that AVH is a low-budget movie with low-budget goals and expectations, but there's just no excuse for writing this bad. Also inexcusable is the film's total lack of regard for vectors and geography. I mean, how does a guy standing perpendicular to his quarry manage to shoot him in the back? As for the film's weird claustrophobic look and feel, it's the result of shooting everything in badly-framed medium shots and close-ups with improper and ill-timed cut-ins and -aways.
It only takes one person to write a bad script, but a lot of people came together to fail at AVH. I simply cannot, for the life of me, understand how this film was made. Who read the script and thought, "Yes! This is just the AVP rip-off I've been looking for, with none of the compelling action or characters seen in those other films!"? Who watched the dailies and said to themselves, "Sweet Jesus, this is just the look I'm looking for, with everyone's heads all cut off above the eyebrows!"? And who was it that watched the final cut and declared, "Goddamn! This is exactly the kind of movie I was hoping for, with all the stilted dialogue, awkward editing, and stalled plots that only The Asylum can deliver!"?
"That's rather harsh," you'd say.
"Yeah, but so was watching this film."
I understand that AVH is a low-budget movie with low-budget goals and expectations, but there's just no excuse for writing this bad. Also inexcusable is the film's total lack of regard for vectors and geography. I mean, how does a guy standing perpendicular to his quarry manage to shoot him in the back? As for the film's weird claustrophobic look and feel, it's the result of shooting everything in badly-framed medium shots and close-ups with improper and ill-timed cut-ins and -aways.
It only takes one person to write a bad script, but a lot of people came together to fail at AVH. I simply cannot, for the life of me, understand how this film was made. Who read the script and thought, "Yes! This is just the AVP rip-off I've been looking for, with none of the compelling action or characters seen in those other films!"? Who watched the dailies and said to themselves, "Sweet Jesus, this is just the look I'm looking for, with everyone's heads all cut off above the eyebrows!"? And who was it that watched the final cut and declared, "Goddamn! This is exactly the kind of movie I was hoping for, with all the stilted dialogue, awkward editing, and stalled plots that only The Asylum can deliver!"?
"That's rather harsh," you'd say.
"Yeah, but so was watching this film."
Labels:
awfulness,
ripoff,
The Asylum
Wednesday, 14 October 2009
iMurders
Though McLuhan's "global village" was a conceptual space in which the instantaneous transmission of information heightened people's awareness, the village was a place of disagreement and discontent. Communication and information didn't breed unity and harmony, only diversity. Thoughtful and compelling arguments can be made for both sides of the issue: on the one hand, the Internet has indeed allowed people to pull away from face-to-face interaction; on the other hand, the Internet has facilitated contact with people across the globe. The contradiction is summed up by Sandra as she explains to Christine that she has one thousand friends on the social networking site "facespace" but doesn't actually know them.
It might seem like old news, but the point is no less valid and is the driving force behind the movie. Simply put, we don't always know who we're talking to online. Now if only the rest of the movie were that straightforward. iMurders is, frankly, a terrible mess of a film.
The story begins with a man caught cheating on his wife. The ensuing argument ends in the death of...someone. Flash forward to ten months later and Sandra is moving in to a new apartment in New Jersey. She makes fast friends with Christine, her landlord, and teaches the woman about computers. Sandra also manages to bed the resident hottie, Joe, a former police officer. Once a week Sandra logs into facespace and enters a chatroom populated by a handful of people around the US. Each month their moderator prepares a game for them to play, and because it's October, the game is to guess the horror movie he's thinking of. As he's introducing the game, the mod is killed and Sandra sees it happen via webcam. But she thinks it's part of the fun. As the various members of the chatroom go about their lives, fewer and fewer log on each week; they're being killed one at a time and Sandra, she realizes, is last on the list.
Meanwhile...Joe is dealing with the death of his brother who was killed by Lindsay's lawyer, the same man who murdered Janet's girlfriend. Professor Uberoth's affair with another teacher is suspected by the granddaughter of Janet's psychiatrist but is ultimately made public by Uberoth's wife. And Joe's sister Lori who is about the close the case on their dead brother discovers that Sandra might be the chatroom killer.
If there was ever a movie suffered from too much plot, this is it. I'm convinced the filmmakers actually lost track of the story at one point. I know I did. What could have been a simple movie about a guy who kills everyone who belongs to this one chat, is instead a convoluted multi-faceted tale of murder (chatroom killer), more murder (ritual slayings), adultery, and overcoming tragedy.
Though the film is badly acted by some of the players, poorly shot, and terribly edited, the worst thing about it is the script. The film focuses on four of the eight or nine people in the weekly chat and goes to rediculous lengths to weave their lives together in an effort to add wholely uncessary depth to the story.
What's more is the police's disvery of the chatroom killer happens entirely outside the story. One day someone is the victim of a brutal attack in their home, and the next a series of seemingly random and disparate murders are connected through the chatroom. Furthermore, at no point are the chat members made aware of the danger, nor do the feds expend any real energy in tracking down the killer.
Now, I understand iMurders is supposed to be a slasher(?), but if you're going to going to introduce the police you have to actually include them in the plot. Because modern slashers are, to a greater or lesser degree, murder mysteries. And the job of the police, regardless of how well they perform their duties, is to solve and prevent crime.
In addition to a badly written and overly plotted script, the film also suffers from an inattention to detail. Lindsay was knifed in a club, her face was cut. But her make up makes her look like a burn victim. The film is supposed to play out over the month of October, and the passage of time is marked by the weekly chats. But it takes the moderator two weeks just to get the game rolling before he's killed and he's the first to die. By all accounts the film should end sometime in mid-November and not around Halloween.
Perhaps most perplexing is the cast. For some reason the cast list includes Charles Durning, William Forsythe, Gabrielle Anwar, Billy Dee Williams, and the Candyman himself, Tony Freaking Todd. I don't know how or why these people are in this movie but thier presence just proves the fact that a good actor can't salvage a bad script.
All that rambling I did at the start of this review, about the complexities of globalization in the age of information comes down to this: In a cunning and twisted act of irony, it was the Internet that brought me into contact with iMurders, a movie I wish I hadn't seen.
It might seem like old news, but the point is no less valid and is the driving force behind the movie. Simply put, we don't always know who we're talking to online. Now if only the rest of the movie were that straightforward. iMurders is, frankly, a terrible mess of a film.
The story begins with a man caught cheating on his wife. The ensuing argument ends in the death of...someone. Flash forward to ten months later and Sandra is moving in to a new apartment in New Jersey. She makes fast friends with Christine, her landlord, and teaches the woman about computers. Sandra also manages to bed the resident hottie, Joe, a former police officer. Once a week Sandra logs into facespace and enters a chatroom populated by a handful of people around the US. Each month their moderator prepares a game for them to play, and because it's October, the game is to guess the horror movie he's thinking of. As he's introducing the game, the mod is killed and Sandra sees it happen via webcam. But she thinks it's part of the fun. As the various members of the chatroom go about their lives, fewer and fewer log on each week; they're being killed one at a time and Sandra, she realizes, is last on the list.
Meanwhile...Joe is dealing with the death of his brother who was killed by Lindsay's lawyer, the same man who murdered Janet's girlfriend. Professor Uberoth's affair with another teacher is suspected by the granddaughter of Janet's psychiatrist but is ultimately made public by Uberoth's wife. And Joe's sister Lori who is about the close the case on their dead brother discovers that Sandra might be the chatroom killer.
If there was ever a movie suffered from too much plot, this is it. I'm convinced the filmmakers actually lost track of the story at one point. I know I did. What could have been a simple movie about a guy who kills everyone who belongs to this one chat, is instead a convoluted multi-faceted tale of murder (chatroom killer), more murder (ritual slayings), adultery, and overcoming tragedy.
Though the film is badly acted by some of the players, poorly shot, and terribly edited, the worst thing about it is the script. The film focuses on four of the eight or nine people in the weekly chat and goes to rediculous lengths to weave their lives together in an effort to add wholely uncessary depth to the story.
What's more is the police's disvery of the chatroom killer happens entirely outside the story. One day someone is the victim of a brutal attack in their home, and the next a series of seemingly random and disparate murders are connected through the chatroom. Furthermore, at no point are the chat members made aware of the danger, nor do the feds expend any real energy in tracking down the killer.
Now, I understand iMurders is supposed to be a slasher(?), but if you're going to going to introduce the police you have to actually include them in the plot. Because modern slashers are, to a greater or lesser degree, murder mysteries. And the job of the police, regardless of how well they perform their duties, is to solve and prevent crime.
In addition to a badly written and overly plotted script, the film also suffers from an inattention to detail. Lindsay was knifed in a club, her face was cut. But her make up makes her look like a burn victim. The film is supposed to play out over the month of October, and the passage of time is marked by the weekly chats. But it takes the moderator two weeks just to get the game rolling before he's killed and he's the first to die. By all accounts the film should end sometime in mid-November and not around Halloween.
Perhaps most perplexing is the cast. For some reason the cast list includes Charles Durning, William Forsythe, Gabrielle Anwar, Billy Dee Williams, and the Candyman himself, Tony Freaking Todd. I don't know how or why these people are in this movie but thier presence just proves the fact that a good actor can't salvage a bad script.
All that rambling I did at the start of this review, about the complexities of globalization in the age of information comes down to this: In a cunning and twisted act of irony, it was the Internet that brought me into contact with iMurders, a movie I wish I hadn't seen.
Monday, 28 September 2009
I Have Poor Taste in Movies

In spite of the fact that 2009 is not yet over, and that frightening Jim Cary animated vehicle A Christmas Carol has yet to hit theatres, Rotten Tomatoes just released their list of 100 worst films of the decade. So I decided to check it out and knew immediately that his was going to go very badly for me. I've seen the first movie on their list. Then I checked out number one, and found, to my shame, that I've seen that one, too.
So here it is, proof that I have, uh, eclectic taste in film:
100 - Whiteout
Had free passes.
48 - BloodRayne
It was on TV. And I only sat through half of it.
47 - Soul Survivors
Seriously, it wasn't terrible. Predictable, but not terrible.
42 - House of the Dead
The only reason I didn't walk out was that we'd all gone to the movies in my car. I can't strand my friends in Kanata, can I? Can I?!?
31 - The Covenant
I think my roommate chose this one.
29 - Bless The Child
Uh, pass.
28 - Rollerball
Jean Reno. Jean Reno!
19 - Half Past Dead
Oh come on. It's a Steven Seagal movie, for chrissakes.
17 - Twisted
Actually, I'm not 100% sure I saw this. I get it confused with another movie that's just like it but the title of which I can never remember.
15 - Alone in the Dark
Omigod was this ever bad! Tara Reid as an archaeologist? Christian Slater as a whatever he was almost made up for it. Almost.
1 - Ballistic: Ecks vs Sever
This proves that I will watch anything with Antonio Banderas in it. That includes ads for Marks and Spencer.
Monday, 17 August 2009
Vampires Vs Zombies
I only watched this movie because of its title. And I only know about this movie because I stumbled upon the DVD art when browsing for another post.
Loosely based on Le Fanu's "Carmilla", a father and daughter agree to help out a stranger by taking her own daughter, Carmilla, with them on their road trip. The group stops off a gas station where Carmilla attacks the attendant out of sight of the Fontaines. Some time later, Carmilla's mother arrives at the gas station, followed by The General, who rescues his kidnapped daughter from the woman. Unfortunately, the girl turns out to be just some random kidnap victim-turned-vampire and is not, in fact, The General's daughter. When The General makes this discovery, he kicks the girl's ass and continues on his way to meet the Fontaines. Meanwhile, Jenna Fontaine, who is prone to nightmares, gets it on with Carmilla. Carmilla bites Jenna, but she doesn't turn into a vampire. Finally, everyone meets up at an old convent where Travis Fontaine and The General attempt to kill Carmilla, ridding the world of her. But Carmilla has other plans, and she and Jenna kill the men so they can be together forever.
But that's not the end of the movie! No, the film actually ends with Travis in the mental hospital, speaking with a doctor about Jenna. It seems that Jenna was commited some time ago but has now run off with one of the nurses. Jenna and nurse Carmilla have holed up in a motel, but their plan to run off togther is foiled by a group of zombies who descend upon them and eat them up.
As I write this, I'm still working out the details of what actually happens in this movie. I think it goes something like this:
There's some kind of zombie plague but it hasn't yet reached zompocalyptic levels so it's of no great concern to the cast. Jenna, however, is crazy but we don't know why and that, too, doesn't seem be all that important. Jenna lives in fantasy world in which both zombies and vampires exist and her repressed homosexuality manifests as Carmilla, her vampire lover. In the real world, Carmilla is a nurse at the mental hospital who's in love with Jenna.
Vampires Vs Zombies is, in a word, terrible. I've only managed to cover half of what actually happens on screen. It's like watching someone get lobotomized: there is some kind of problem to start with and when it's done, there are more, different issues and the damage is irreversible. Needless to say, the fact that the promised face off between the vampires and the zombies never happens, is the least of this movie's problems. The only versus in this film seems to be a vying for narrative control, and it's a multi-way stalemate between vampires, zombies, Jenna's psychosis, and Travis Fontaine.
Loosely based on Le Fanu's "Carmilla", a father and daughter agree to help out a stranger by taking her own daughter, Carmilla, with them on their road trip. The group stops off a gas station where Carmilla attacks the attendant out of sight of the Fontaines. Some time later, Carmilla's mother arrives at the gas station, followed by The General, who rescues his kidnapped daughter from the woman. Unfortunately, the girl turns out to be just some random kidnap victim-turned-vampire and is not, in fact, The General's daughter. When The General makes this discovery, he kicks the girl's ass and continues on his way to meet the Fontaines. Meanwhile, Jenna Fontaine, who is prone to nightmares, gets it on with Carmilla. Carmilla bites Jenna, but she doesn't turn into a vampire. Finally, everyone meets up at an old convent where Travis Fontaine and The General attempt to kill Carmilla, ridding the world of her. But Carmilla has other plans, and she and Jenna kill the men so they can be together forever.
But that's not the end of the movie! No, the film actually ends with Travis in the mental hospital, speaking with a doctor about Jenna. It seems that Jenna was commited some time ago but has now run off with one of the nurses. Jenna and nurse Carmilla have holed up in a motel, but their plan to run off togther is foiled by a group of zombies who descend upon them and eat them up.
As I write this, I'm still working out the details of what actually happens in this movie. I think it goes something like this:
There's some kind of zombie plague but it hasn't yet reached zompocalyptic levels so it's of no great concern to the cast. Jenna, however, is crazy but we don't know why and that, too, doesn't seem be all that important. Jenna lives in fantasy world in which both zombies and vampires exist and her repressed homosexuality manifests as Carmilla, her vampire lover. In the real world, Carmilla is a nurse at the mental hospital who's in love with Jenna.
Vampires Vs Zombies is, in a word, terrible. I've only managed to cover half of what actually happens on screen. It's like watching someone get lobotomized: there is some kind of problem to start with and when it's done, there are more, different issues and the damage is irreversible. Needless to say, the fact that the promised face off between the vampires and the zombies never happens, is the least of this movie's problems. The only versus in this film seems to be a vying for narrative control, and it's a multi-way stalemate between vampires, zombies, Jenna's psychosis, and Travis Fontaine.
Wednesday, 25 October 2006
Trailer Reviews
We've all seen them, movie trailers that reveal too much about the film, or show all the best parts. Some trailers are so poorly edited that you can't actually see anything at all. And then there are the unfortunate cases where the trailers mislead us into thinking the movie is one thing when it's something else all together.
So with this in mind, I've started logging my insights. Each installment of this ongoing project will feature a one or two trailers and my over-analysis of each. And as we move forward, we'll see just how much of a know-it-all I really am.
Some will say I think too much. I say, not too much enough!
The Hills Run Red
Whiteout
Carriers
Surrogates
Legion
The Vampire's Assistant
Frozen
Splice
Buried
The Unleashed
Bioshock Infinite
The Colony
Percy Jackson 2: Sea of Monsters
Annabelle
Infini
Point Break (2015)
Ouija: Origin of Evil
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)




